Blog
Haima Super Interview Episode 14 | Legal Risks Faced During the Process of Issuing Securities Overseas

Produced by: Haima Institute
Edited by: Xiao Jin

Haima Super Interview is jointly launched by "Cloud Creation Future Master Lecture Hall" and Golden Box Enterprise Management Group, aiming to explore the insights of successful entrepreneurs, experts and scholars in business management and commercial practice.
On the road to pursuing business success, going public is undoubtedly an important milestone. However, the IPO process will also face numerous legal challenges and risks.
On May 30, 2023, the online live broadcast of 【Haima Super Interview】 Column Issue 14: "How to Evaluate and Address Legal Risks in the Process of Overseas Securities Issuance?" was held as scheduled, hosted by Haima Institute and co-hosted by Cloud Creation Future and Golden Box Enterprise Management Group.
This episode specially invited Lawyer Li Songwei, Senior Partner of Yingke Shanghai and Leading Talent of Foreign Lawyers of the All China Lawyers Association, as a guest in the live studio of 【Haima Super Interview】. He in-depth analyzed possible legal issues in the IPO process, such as compliance requirements, information disclosure, equity structure, etc., to answer questions for entrepreneurs. Whether it is a start-up company just starting out, or a mature enterprise aspiring for higher growth, this interview will provide valuable guidance and inspiration for everyone.
Without further ado, let's take a look at the key takeaways! (This article is an edited version of the live broadcast)
Follow the WeChat official account to book the online live broadcast of Haima Super Interview!
Li Songwei Special Guest of This Episode
Beijing Yingke Law Firm Shanghai Office
Senior Partner Lawyer
Leading Talent of Foreign Lawyers of the All China Lawyers Association
Received industry recognitions at the regional, municipal and national levels
Registered arbitrator of Shanghai International Arbitration Center and other arbitration commissions, member of Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (CIArb), independent director of Chinese listed companies.
Professional fields cover overseas listing, venture capital and private equity, funds and trusts, foreign investment and overseas investment, mergers and acquisitions, offshore company affairs, high-tech and TMT, construction and real estate, commercial arbitration and litigation, English contract negotiation and drafting, etc.
Representative Cases:
5 companies listed on NASDAQ Main Board, over 20 companies listed on US OTC Market, numerous private equity financings with amounts exceeding 100 million yuan, and multiple industry pioneering successful cases.
Books Participated in Compilation:
"The Growth Path of Young Lawyers in Shanghai"
"Selected Classic Cases of King & Wood Mallesons"
"Into Wall Street"
"Practice of Chinese Concept Stocks Listing and Privatization Re-listing" (Series of Lectures)
Jiao Shike Host
Co-founder of Haima Super Interview
Financial PR Consultant
Senior Financial Journalist
Previously worked at well-known investment institutions and financial media, and has authored several industry research reports.
First Question
Host - Jiao Shike:
In the process of preparing for a U.S. listing, what do you believe is the most important legal and compliance preparation?
Guest - Li Songwei:
As a lawyer, I would say every enterprise should be fully legally compliant. Whether a company is listing in the U.S. or other international capital markets, sufficient attention must be paid by the company's leadership. The company should maintain standard operations in daily work and conduct a review before the listing. Of course, full legal compliance is the overall goal, but in specific work, three aspects can be prioritized.
The first aspect is organizational structure compliance.
This means that the company's establishment and historical evolution must comply with the requirements of Chinese laws, especially the Company Law. For example, is the company's articles of association standardized? Are its shareholders and management qualified? Is the company's governance standardized? Are shareholders' meetings and board meetings held and conducted in accordance with procedures? Also, if the company was a state-owned enterprise in its history, was its restructuring process legal? Has the company's registered capital been fully paid up, or was the payment made in a standardized manner, without using non-valuable assets for payment? We also need to check whether there have been any penalties for non-compliance in the company's history.
Additionally, when a company goes public, it needs to build an overseas structure based on its domestic operations. We must ensure that the entire structure is built in a legally compliant manner, and that the result of the structure is legally compliant. Are there any violations of Chinese laws and regulations? For example, whether it violates the Provisions on the Acquisition of Domestic Enterprises by Foreign Investors, the Notice on Foreign Exchange Administration Related to Overseas Investment and Financing and Round-Trip Investment by Domestic Residents through Special Purpose Companies, and other relevant laws and regulations.
Another point is that during the overseas listing process, if there are some companies in the group established outside China, do these overseas companies comply with local laws and regulations? For instance, if you set up a company in Singapore, according to Singaporean law, one of the company's directors must be a local resident. That is, if the company has two to three directors, at least one must be a Singaporean resident. You also need to meet the legal requirements of the listing jurisdiction. For example, the U.S. requires listed companies to have more independent directors than directors appointed by shareholders, and the board's compensation committee, nomination committee, and audit committee must all be composed of independent directors.
The second aspect is business compliance, including that the company's business scope must comply with laws and regulations on foreign investment management, business activities must be conducted properly, commercial opportunities and profits must not be obtained through corruption, and laws and regulations such as labor laws and anti-monopoly laws must be followed.
Finally, the third aspect is that financial and tax matters must be legally compliant, with standardized accounting, sound internal controls, and tax payments in accordance with the law.
I would like to reiterate that every enterprise should be fully legally compliant. Whether a company is listing in the U.S. or other international capital markets, sufficient attention must be paid by the company's leadership. The company should maintain standard operations in daily work and conduct a review before the listing. Of course, full legal compliance is the overall goal, but in specific work, three aspects can be prioritized.
Second Question
Host - Jiao Shike:
The China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC) requires that Chinese companies listed overseas must go through the record-filing process. What preparations do companies need to make and what risks should they note?
(Background: On February 17, 2023, with the approval of the State Council, the China Securities Regulatory Commission (hereinafter referred to as the "CSRC") issued a total of 6 institutional rules related to the record-filing management of overseas listings, including the "Interim Measures for the Administration of Overseas Securities Issuance and Listing by Domestic Enterprises" (hereinafter referred to as the "Interim Measures") and 5 supporting guidelines, which have been implemented since March 31, 2023. On February 24, 2023, the CSRC, together with the Ministry of Finance, the State Administration for Protection of State Secrets, and the National Archives Administration, issued the "Provisions on Strengthening the Confidentiality and Archive Management Work Related to Overseas Securities Issuance and Listing by Domestic Enterprises", which has been implemented simultaneously with the Interim Measures since March 31, 2023.)
Guest - Li Songwei:
As the host just mentioned, starting from March 31 this year, China has implemented the "Interim Measures for the Administration of Overseas Securities Issuance and Listing by Domestic Enterprises" and supporting guidelines. These interim measures and guidelines are collectively referred to as the new regulatory rules in our industry.
The implication of this new rule is that previously, domestic companies issuing H shares in Hong Kong needed to go through the CSRC's review. Now, all Chinese companies going public overseas, whether directly issuing H shares overseas or indirectly listing by incorporating themselves under an overseas listed parent company, will be included in the CSRC's regulatory system. This is the largest institutional change in the 20+ year history of Chinese companies listing overseas.
In the context of this major institutional change, I believe companies need to consider preparations in various aspects.
First, be mentally prepared, and familiarize yourself with and carefully study and understand the spirit of the new regulatory rules.
Second, make human resources preparations, meaning you need to have appropriate personnel, including the company's internal legal and securities staff, and also hire external professionals. In particular, the company's leadership should attach importance to and participate in this process.
Third, make document preparations. As a company, you should establish and improve your own archives, whether financial, business, or organizational.
Fourth, prepare for responses during the record-filing process. Because the CSRC will raise various inquiries after receiving the materials, we should fully prepare to respond to them.
Fifth, be prepared for coordination.Are the documents submitted for record-filing consistent with other supporting documents, and are the documents for domestic record-filing consistent with the overseas prospectus for listing? All of these require careful review and coordination.
As for the risk points that enterprises need to pay attention to during the domestic record-filing process, I initially think there are 5 points that need to be addressed and avoided. First, if you fail to file the required records, it may lead to your inability to go public, and you may even be blacklisted, making it difficult to enter the capital market in the future. Second, if your preparation is insufficient, there is a high risk of record-filing failure. Therefore, you need to be prepared in terms of mentality, manpower, etc., as I mentioned earlier. Third, there is the risk of false disclosure. Your materials must be authentic. If the materials you submit are false, they may be detected by the staff of the China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC), as they have many years of experience in the capital market. Fourth, there is the risk of lack of supporting documents. If you do not keep your documents properly, even if your arguments are reasonable, you cannot provide supporting documents as evidence, so your record-filing may be difficult to pass. Fifth, there must be no contradictions among various documents. Where there are contradictions, you will be seriously and repeatedly questioned and inquired about. This may lead to delays in your listing process due to time, even if you finally pass the record-filing.
Therefore, I believe that when facing new regulatory rules, you must keep in mind that overseas listing now involves two reviews: one is by the securities regulatory authority and exchange of the listing location, and the other is by the CSRC of our country. Therefore, you must do a good job in both aspects.
Host - Jiao Shike:
Recently, I have also noticed on the official website of China's CSRC some information about enterprises needing to supplement materials for record-filing. Many entrepreneurs feel confused when seeing such information and do not know how to deal with it. I believe Lawyer Li can give us a lot of professional advice.
Guest - Li Songwei:
Yes, we can provide special legal services in the area of domestic record-filing, which is to assist enterprises in doing a good job in record-filing. For example, when the CSRC gives feedback on comments, how we submit materials and provide explanations to the CSRC from the perspective of legality, compliance and basis.
Third question
Host - Jiao Shike:
What legal risks should enterprises pay attention to when establishing an overseas structure during the listing process?
Guest - Li Songwei:
Establishing an overseas structure is a necessary step for domestic enterprises in the process of indirect overseas listing. From my personal experience, there are usually three types of risks that need to be avoided in this regard.
The first type of risk to avoid is the risk of violating legality.
First and foremost, it is necessary to comply with China's laws and regulations, because our earliest or most important enterprises are located within the territory. Additionally, China's laws and regulations also apply to Chinese entrepreneurs. For example, the regulations on the merger and acquisition of domestic enterprises by foreign investors and the circular on the relevant regulations on overseas investment and financing and foreign exchange administration of domestic residents through special purpose companies that I mentioned earlier are all laws and regulations that entrepreneurs must be familiar with and abide by. Lawyers who help entrepreneurs set up overseas structures must also be very familiar with these laws and regulations. There are also other laws and regulations that need to be taken seriously. For instance, when setting up a VIE structure, new regulatory rules require that enterprises adopting a VIE structure must obtain recognition from the relevant Chinese authorities.
Furthermore, during the process of building the overseas structure of your enterprise group, you will definitely need to establish subsidiaries of your group company in other countries and regions, which also requires compliance with local laws and regulations. For example, paying taxes in accordance with local laws, reporting the financial status of your local subsidiary in accordance with the law, and so on. In addition, you also need to comply with the laws and regulations of the listing location. For example, if you go public in the United States, if the number of independent directors of your company is less than the number required by law, then it will definitely be impossible to go public. Therefore, abiding by the law is the first key point in responding to risks.
The second type of risk to avoid is the risk of restructuring errors.
The restructuring process requires the assistance of professionals with certain experience. I often encounter some securities firms or financing consultants coming to me, saying that a certain enterprise wants to list in Hong Kong or the United States, but its structure is set up incorrectly. This is actually a very awkward matter, because once the error occurs, it will persist. Now, the electronic archives of domestic enterprise changes are all entered into the State Administration for Market Regulation and cannot be altered or revoked. Therefore, if some errors occur during the restructuring process, it may easily lead to huge risks, such as the risk that the newly established company and the old company cannot consolidate their financial statements. If this unfortunately happens, it may cause the entire listing process to restart after two or three years.
The third type of risk to avoid is the risk of excessive restructuring costs.
Restructuring is also a technical task. For example, during the restructuring process, many Chinese enterprises will establish the overseas parent company intended for listing in the Cayman Islands. If you set the share capital of the Cayman company too large, you may have to pay higher annual maintenance fees locally in the future, and this will continue indefinitely. Therefore, there are skills in restructuring, and it is recommended that entrepreneurs find experienced professionals to assist them, such as hiring experienced lawyers.
Fourth Question
Host - Jiao Shike:
In cross-border mergers and acquisitions and restructurings, what legal issues should enterprises planning to list in the US pay attention to?
Guest - Li Songwei:
Carrying out cross-border mergers and acquisitions and restructurings before listing is a common phenomenon for enterprises planning to go public.
I think cross-border mergers and acquisitions (M&A) and restructurings should be divided into two types.
The first type is cross-border M&A and restructurings between related enterprises.
Some entrepreneurs not only have relatively mature enterprises in mainland China, but have also established some production enterprises or sales enterprises overseas, etc. The ultimate actual controller of these domestic and foreign enterprises is still the Chinese entrepreneur. The M&A and restructurings between these enterprises, strictly speaking, are just corporate restructurings, which organize some related enterprises into a corporate group.
In this process, first of all, laws and regulations must be followed, including the rules for foreign investment M&A and the regulations for Chinese residents' round-trip investment I mentioned earlier, as well as the tax laws of various countries, and tax evasion and avoidance must not occur during the restructuring process.
Secondly, during the restructuring process between related enterprises, external private equity investors may be introduced, which will bring capital to the enterprise, and may also bring some connections or business opportunities. When introducing private equity investment, attention should be paid to ensuring that entrepreneurs do not lose control of the enterprise intended to be listed, meaning the original actual controller must maintain the actual control position. In addition, the operation process must be carried out in a standardized and legal manner.
In addition, during restructuring, some employees may take equity shares, or various related parties may also take equity shares. Therefore, attention should be paid to the number of shareholders, which must not exceed 200. According to current Chinese regulations, the maximum number of shareholders for an enterprise intended to be listed is 200, and sometimes the number must be counted through penetration. Exceeding 200 people is easily suspected of illegal fundraising, and illegal fundraising is not a simple civil matter, but may involve criminal risks. Therefore, everyone must pay attention to controlling the number of shareholders. If there are any doubts, you can consult professional legal professionals.
Furthermore, when conducting M&A and restructurings between related enterprises, do not place multiple companies engaged in the same business inside and outside the group respectively. Otherwise, it will lead to business competition between the corporate group preparing for listing and the enterprises not participating in the listing, and both parties are under the control of the same actual controller. Business competition is unacceptable to any securities regulatory authority and also unacceptable to the vast number of investors in the market. It is a red line, without exception.
The second type is cross-border M&A and restructurings with non-related enterprises. The legal issues that should be paid attention to are:
First, pay attention to maintaining the control right unchanged during the operation process.
Second, do not let M&A and restructurings reduce the efficiency of the enterprise. Especially when you want to acquire an enterprise with poor performance, you need to consider whether the resulting profit reduction or loss will affect the possibility of successful listing? Will it make your financial statements look bad?
Third, the entire M&A process must be very standardized. For matters involving equity changes, registration must be carried out at the corresponding registration authority, whether it is the State Administration for Market Regulation in China or the company registry in foreign countries, registration is required.
Finally, I would like to remind enterprises intended to be listed: do not engage in fake M&A purely for the sake of good numbers. There is no wall that does not let the wind through. If you engage in fake M&A, you are likely to be reported, leading to the failure of the entire listing process. When doing M&A, it must be real M&A. As for whether a real M&A can be split in the future, that is a technical issue and can be discussed with professionals.
Question 5
Moderator - Jiao Shike:
How should enterprises handle the registration and approval procedures with U.S. securities regulators (such as the SEC) to ensure a successful listing in the U.S.?
Guest - Li Songwei:
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is an independent agency of the U.S. government, established in accordance with U.S. law. If our company wants to list in the U.S., we will inevitably deal with U.S. regulators, such as the SEC. How to engage with them? I think we can consider three aspects.
The first aspect is to understand how U.S. securities regulators regulate listing activities and trading activities.
U.S. securities regulators, represented by the SEC, have three characteristics: First, legalization. The establishment and exercise of authority of the U.S. SEC are based on law, and every action it takes must have a legal basis. Second, marketization. For purely market-related issues, such as stock prices, they actually do not care much. They only care whether you have operated in compliance with regulations. Did you drive the stock price up or down through insider trading, or was it a normal market reaction? If it is a normal market reaction, they will stand aside, no matter how unreasonable or absurd you think the stock price is. If the sharp change in stock price is caused by insider trading or stock price manipulation, then regardless of whether the result is good or bad, they will definitely intervene. Third, transparency. The feature of the U.S. SEC's review work is: taking filing documents as the carrier, information disclosure as the core, and compliance as the focus. The department in charge of listing business at the U.S. SEC is called the Division of Corporation Finance. This department usually has nearly 100 staff, most of whom are securities professionals with a background in law or auditing. It should be quite difficult for enterprises to try to cut corners.
The second aspect is that enterprises must establish an appropriate professional team.
As the moderator mentioned earlier, professionals do professional things. If your company wants to list in the U.S. and deal with U.S. regulators, you must have an appropriate team.
On the enterprise side, we recommend that the company's chairman lead the team, and also equip assistants with certain work capabilities to assist. Because listing involves major institutional changes for the enterprise, it should not be taken lightly.
For auditors, the enterprise should hire a qualified U.S. audit firm that is a member of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB). It is best if they have experience auditing in China, so that they can easily understand some of the characteristics of our Chinese culture, system, and business, and communication will also be easier.
In addition, it is essential to hire U.S. lawyers to help you prepare filing documents and organize responses to inquiries from U.S. regulators.
As for Chinese lawyers, it is recommended to hire Chinese lawyers with considerable knowledge and experience in overseas listings.
For securities firms, we recommend choosing international investment banks or local US investment banks with strong financing capabilities.
If the company’s own organizational capabilities are not strong, it can also hire a competent financing advisor to help organize the listing activities and assist in assembling the professional team for the listing.
The third aspect is that companies should approach interactions with US regulatory authorities with a normal mindset and follow normal procedures.
First, do not try to take shortcuts, especially pay attention to anti-corruption issues. Americans basically operate according to procedures, and using personal connections does not work well in the US. We just need to do our own things properly. The US has a system of huge rewards for whistleblowers to combat corruption. You may have heard recent reports that the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) awarded hundreds of millions of dollars to whistleblowers. If a corruption case is known in the US, the whistleblower will be very happy because they can legally make a fortune.
Second, follow normal procedures. Submit the application only after preparations are mature, consider all matters thoroughly, and prepare the documents properly—do not be too hasty. Do not rush the timeline and turn the listing work into a half-baked job.
Third, actively solve problems. After submitting the application materials, the US SEC will definitely conduct inquiries. For this, we need to respond to each round of inquiries in a timely manner—do not be timid or overly aggressive. As long as there are no major obstacles to the listing, we should continue to work hard, disclose defects based on facts, and provide solutions. Do not retreat just because of a sharp inquiry. For a company to be listed, everyone works very hard, sometimes it feels like shedding a layer of skin. Therefore, entrepreneurs should maintain a normal mindset, work with professionals to pool ideas, address issues based on facts, and solve problems. In that case, there is more hope for success.
Sixth Question
Host - Jiao Shike:
What specific impacts and restrictions do cross-border capital flows and foreign exchange controls have on Chinese companies planning to list in the US?
Guest - Li Songwei:
Currently, China is still a country that implements foreign exchange controls. The RMB, as our only legal currency, cannot achieve cross-border free circulation and convertibility. It can only be circulated and converted in a limited manner between certain countries under specific circumstances. There is still a long way to go for the internationalization of the RMB.
For entrepreneurs, in the face of this situation, the first thing is to have the concept of legality and compliance. When handling cross-border capital flows, they need to abide by China’s foreign exchange and RMB-related laws and regulations, such as the Foreign Exchange Administration Regulations, the Measures for the Administration of Individual Foreign Exchange, the Detailed Rules for the Implementation of the Measures for the Administration of Individual Foreign Exchange, the Foreign Exchange Administration Regulations for Round-Trip Investment by Domestic Residents, and the RMB Management Regulations, etc. These laws and regulations reflect the country’s basic foreign exchange system, including: the system of not restricting current international payments and transfers, the balance of payments statistical reporting system, the system prohibiting the circulation of foreign currency within the territory, the foreign exchange registration system for foreign investment, the registration system for overseas direct investment, and the approval system for external guarantees, etc.
Therefore, during the entire listing process, I think companies may need to pay special attention to the following points.
First, transactions between enterprises within a group must also comply with laws and regulations. It cannot be said that just because everyone is an affiliated enterprise, they do not need to follow foreign exchange regulations. If loans are made between different enterprises within a corporate group, once they cross borders, they fall under external debt and require external debt registration. If a domestic enterprise provides a guarantee to its overseas affiliated company, it must also go through foreign-related guarantee approval.
Second, if our enterprises successfully list overseas or obtain private placement, the raised funds should basically be repatriated to China in accordance with current domestic regulations. They can be used to increase capital in the original domestic enterprises, or to establish new foreign-invested enterprises. Of course, a small portion can remain overseas for international business operations, but in principle, they should be repatriated to China as much as possible.
Third, always pay attention to changes in foreign exchange management policies. The foreign exchange management system is a very strict system in our country. Violations will result in fines at the minimum, and may even be linked to criminal risks such as foreign exchange speculation at the maximum. I suggest that when dealing with cross-border capital flows, entrepreneurs should be vigilant and consult more.
Question 7
Host - Jiao Shike:
What are the information disclosure requirements in the US securities market?
Guest - Li Songwei:
The United States is a very special country. The core of its capital market regulation is the information disclosure system.
This is a rather long story.
As everyone knows, the United States experienced a global financial crisis in the late 1920s, which some even say was the trigger for World War II. At that time, U.S. regulators had almost no substantive oversight over the capital market, and speculation was rampant. After the Great Depression, during the presidency of Franklin D. Roosevelt, the U.S. Congress passed relevant laws, established a regulatory system centered on information disclosure, and created the Securities and Exchange Commission. This regulatory system is mainly reflected in two important U.S. laws: the Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Nearly 90 years have passed, and most of the basic systems established by these two laws are still applicable to the U.S. capital market today.
In the early 2000s, the Enron scandal and the WorldCom fraud occurred. These two major cases made many Americans realize that there were loopholes in the original regulatory system. Therefore, in 2002 during the presidency of George W. Bush, the United States enacted and implemented the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, whose Chinese translation is the "Public Company Accounting Reform and Investor Protection Act" — it aims to protect the interests of investors by reforming the accounting system. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act is a quite strict law that has made significant reforms to the original regulatory system. For example, pursuant to this act, the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board, or PCAOB, which I mentioned earlier, was established. All accounting firms must be members of this organization. In addition, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act requires enterprises to strengthen internal control, and also requires accounting firms that audit the same enterprise to not provide both consulting services and audit services to that enterprise. In short, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act has tightened regulatory oversight.
After the 2008 financial crisis, there were more calls in American society for strengthening financial system reforms. During President Obama's tenure, the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act was enacted in 2010. It is a comprehensive financial reform law, and a part of it relates to the capital market. For example, it requires that the compensation of listed company executives must be approved by the shareholders' meeting to be legal, and this requirement is quite strict. But two years later, the situation changed again, because many enterprises reflected that large enterprises might have no problem operating in accordance with this law, but for some small and medium-sized enterprises, the compliance cost was really too high.
Therefore, during President Obama's tenure, the Jumpstart Our Business Startups Act (JOBS Act) was introduced in 2012 to support emerging growth companies. Companies with annual revenue below 1 billion U.S. dollars can enjoy the benefits of this law. What does this mean? It means that some of the stricter provisions of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act can be relaxed a bit. For example, some stricter provisions can be implemented five years after listing. In addition, previously, to apply for listing, audited financial statements for the three years before listing were required, but according to the JOBS Act, small and medium-sized enterprises only need to provide two years of audited financial statements, which is a huge benefit for many small and medium-sized enterprises. Audit costs are saved, audit time is shortened, and the burden on enterprises is reduced. In addition, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act also relaxed the requirements for internal control reports. Of course, enterprises still need to establish internal control systems. Moreover, according to the JOBS Act, small and medium-sized enterprises can also privately inquire with qualified institutional investors before listing to see if they are interested in buying the enterprise's stock. Of course, private offerings to public investors are still not allowed. After the JOBS Act was passed, it was a huge benefit for small and medium-sized enterprises, especially Chinese enterprises, to list in the United States, because many Chinese enterprises are still in the growth stage according to international standards.
However, there has long been an issue between China and the United States: according to the U.S. system, the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) can inspect the work of every audit firm, including their audit working papers. On this issue, the systems of some countries in the world, including China, do not allow the provision of audit working papers to foreign countries. Historically, more than 300 Chinese enterprises have listed in the United States, including those that have delisted after listing.
In 2020, during President Trump's tenure, the U.S. Congress enacted the Holding Foreign Companies Accountable Act. According to this law, if the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board is not allowed to review the audit working papers of the accounting firm that conducts audits for three consecutive years, the audited company will be delisted from the U.S. market.
In August 2022, two years later, the China Securities Regulatory Commission, the Ministry of Finance, and the U.S. Public Company Accounting Oversight Board reached an agreement. This issue between China and the United States has been resolved. Based on the principle of reciprocity, the two sides cooperate in regulatory affairs. The audit working papers of Chinese firms can be kept in their Hong Kong offices and reviewed by the U.S. side under the supervision of the China Securities Regulatory Commission. Thus, the haze of the issue has been cleared, and the path for Chinese enterprises to list in the United States has become smoother again.
In summary, information disclosure is a legal issue and a set of rules. So, how is it implemented in practice? Generally, enterprises listing in the United States disclose information by submitting documents in a fixed format to U.S. regulatory authorities. Let me briefly introduce this:
When a company applies for listing, it must submit a stock registration statement, usually in the form of Form S-1 or Form F-1. An important part of this is the prospectus, as well as attachments such as audit reports, and our lawyers' legal opinions, etc.
After a company goes public, it must file audited annual reports every year, typically in the form of 10-K or 20-F. Quarterly reports, such as Form 10-Q, must be submitted each quarter. Quarterly reports do not require an audit, only a review by an accountant.
If a listed company experiences any major event, it must report in a timely manner, usually in the form of Form 8-K.
Directors, senior executives, and major shareholders are required to file reports with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), and must file a pre-transaction notice and a post-transaction report when reducing holdings.
If a listed company wants to privatize and delist, it must also file a registration withdrawal application.
In summary, when listing in the U.S., it is essential to remember that the core is the information disclosure system. Whether the news is good or bad, you must truly disclose the situation transparently.
Question 8
Host - Jiao Shike:
In U.S. securities exchanges, what key trading mechanisms and market rules need to be understood and complied with?
Guest - Li Songwei:
The trading rules of the New York Stock Exchange and NASDAQ in the U.S. are not exactly the same; each has detailed trading systems. Today, I will mention some common and important trading mechanisms among them.
The first is the T+0 trading system. Unlike China's A-share market, U.S. stocks allow buying and selling on the same day.
The second is that U.S. securities exchanges have a market circuit breaker mechanism, which may suspend trading or even close early across the entire exchange. If the market drops by more than 7%, a circuit breaker may be triggered. If it drops by another 13%, another circuit breaker will occur. If the market drops by 20% in a day, trading will be suspended for the rest of the day. The purpose of the circuit breaker is to allow participants in the stock market to calm down. A market circuit breaker is different from a stock-specific trading halt. If an individual stock has a large price fluctuation within a short period, it will usually be suspended for a few minutes. However, a market circuit breaker is based on the overall market index.
The third is the short selling mechanism in the U.S. Unlike China's A-share margin trading which is restricted, short selling is completely legal in the U.S. with basically no restrictions. They believe that the short selling mechanism can eliminate bad stocks in the market. As the Chinese saying goes, "A straight foot is not afraid of a crooked shoe," Americans share a similar mindset.
Fourth, it is important to note that the U.S. has a market maker system. Different from China's A-share market which now uses an advanced fully electronic centralized auction trading, U.S. market makers provide two-way quotes, which may have a small spread. Of course, this is regulated by a set of rules from the National Association of Securities Dealers (NASD). If a company wants to list on NASDAQ in the U.S., it must retain at least three market makers to successfully list, and these market makers must be members of the NASD.
Fifth, the U.S. also has a block trading system. In general terms, the block trading system is not very different from that in China, but there are some obvious differences in small details.
Finally, let me mention the major shareholder reduction system.I think this is a question that many entrepreneurs are particularly concerned about. In the United States, the major shareholder reduction system is very different from China's A-share market. If a major shareholder wants to reduce their holdings, they must report to the US Securities and Exchange Commission at least 15 days in advance, publicly disclose the reduction plan, and report the reduction situation after the actual reduction, accepting supervision. This is very different from China's A-share post-reporting system. How to view this? Different positions lead to different perceptions.
Ninth Question
Host - Jiao Shike:
In your practice, have you encountered serious consequences due to risks in client securities issuance? How can entrepreneurs be aware of and prevent these in advance?
Guest - Li Songwei:
I have been a lawyer for over 30 years, more than 20 of which were mainly serving the capital market, and I have dealt with enterprises from all walks of life. Of course, I cannot disclose my clients' names, so I can only talk about the risks caused by improper issuance activities from my personal experience.
First aspect: the risks caused by improper issuance or similar activities before listing.
First, let's talk about non-standard employee stock ownership plans. I know that many consulting firms or consulting companies in society, and even a small number of lawyers, are helping enterprises set up non-standard employee stock ownership plans. Enterprises and entrepreneurs must be cautious about this. If the employee stock ownership plan is not done properly, it may become an obstacle to listing.
Why? First, if there are too many shareholders, we need to consider whether there is a suspicion of illegal fundraising. Second, even if the number of shareholders is legal, since there are many documents to be signed during the listing process, how much time will it take to collect signatures from so many shareholders? Whether the signatures can be collected in time becomes a problem. Third, many things during the listing process need to be kept confidential. With so many minority shareholders holding a small share, it is difficult to keep things confidential. Fourth, if there are many shareholders, will it cause a dilemma of exceeding the number of shareholders after mergers and acquisitions? Therefore, the employee stock ownership plan is a very professional matter. Do not do it lightly, do not do it casually, and do not do it non-standardly, because it will be relatively difficult to correct later.
Therefore, my recommended preventive measure is to standardize the operation of the employee stock ownership plan, especially to control the total number of participants, only allowing technical experts and management personnel who have made significant contributions to the company to participate. Do not make it too large or too messy.
Secondly, let's talk about employee stock option plans before listing, this issue is even more serious. Many consulting firms outside are telling you how to set up options. However, I have to seriously remind everyone that I believe real employee stock option plans can only be implemented by listed companies. Employee options implemented by non-listed companies are mostly deceptive. Why? Non-listed companies do not have a public stock market, so what is the value of your options? Apart from setting traps for entrepreneurs and drawing big pies for employees, they have little practical significance. Even if you don't care about practical significance and just want to have one for show, please consult a financial expert. As far as I know, such so-called plans may likely increase the company's financial costs and make your financial statements look worse. When you go public, auditors may require you to make provisions for expenses. Therefore, for employee stock option plans, I recommend you do them after listing. Before listing, you can have some ideas and communicate orally, but generally it is not recommended to make them written. Don't complicate the listing process, which is already difficult enough, there is no need to add more burdens. Therefore, my recommended preventive measure is to implement a standardized option plan after the company goes public.
Thirdly, let's talk about non-standard equity incentive plans. As far as I know, there are so-called two or three dozen equity incentive plans outside. Let me tell you, I believe there are only two real equity incentive plans. One is the option plan after listing, which allows contributing employees to buy the company's stock at a relatively low price. This is the first type. The second type is direct awarded stock, or restricted stock. For various other equity incentive plans, I think most of them are not worthy of the name. For example, virtual stock, for example, rewards based on simulated stock prices. In reality, they are just bonuses with different names, not real equity incentives. The so-called corruption in language is the biggest corruption.
Some so-called equity incentive plans themselves mean that entrepreneurs give some of their shares to employees. Then entrepreneurs have to consider for themselves: if it is appropriate, they should give them if they should, or sell them to employees at a low price if that is appropriate. My point is that if it is essentially a bonus, just handle it as a bonus. Don't attribute everything to equity incentives.
My risk prevention suggestions are: handle bonuses as bonuses, handle stock gifts as stock gifts, handle stock purchases as stock purchases, and proceed normally according to the rules. Being practical and realistic is simpler. If there are too many tricks, too many names, too many deceptions, it will instead increase the difficulty of listing.
Second aspect: the risks caused by improper issuance or similar activities during the listing process.
I often encounter some entrepreneurs who do not pay attention to the rules in this regard, they publicly offer shares in advance. Private communication is no problem, but public offering must be approved. When can you advertise publicly and publicly ask relatives and friends to buy your company's stock? In the United States, you have to at least make your prospectus public for a period of time. Under the JOBS Act, small businesses can submit prospectuses confidentially, at which point you cannot publicly offer shares. The recommended preventive measure is to consult your American lawyer and American broker-dealer about when you can advertise publicly and publicly persuade people to buy your company's stock.
The second problem encountered during the listing process is irregular prospectus offering. Some entrepreneurs think: "My friends are willing to buy my company's stock, so can I not go through a broker-dealer?" No, you still have to go through a broker-dealer. Otherwise, the money your friends use to buy your company's stock cannot enter the company's account, and you cannot treat it as private money. In addition, if you don't go through formal channels, the stocks your friends buy cannot be issued to them. Therefore, I recommend going through formal channels for prospectus offering, which can avoid such risks.
Host - Jiao Shike:
The two major points just mentioned are what enterprises need to pay special attention to during the listing process. One is about improper issuance before the company's listing and issuance, and the other is about the prospectus offering sector, which involves publicly releasing some information and publicly sharing stocks, which may affect the listing and even violate relevant securities laws and regulations, right?
Guest - Li Songwei:
That's right. In the United States, any act that violates securities laws and regulations may face three types of countermeasures: one is an administrative investigation, which may result in fines; another is a class action lawsuit, which may result in compensation;
and the third is a criminal prosecution, which has the most serious consequences. I remember that a few years ago, an entrepreneur from Hong Kong was wanted by the United States for violating securities laws in the United States. I think, in the securities market, the legal path will eventually work out sooner or later. If some entrepreneurs encounter difficulties and feel they can't get through, I will ask you two questions: First, is your enterprise profitable when operating legally? Second, is your enterprise in a non-sunset industry? As long as your enterprise is profitable and not in a sunset industry, under normal circumstances, you have the possibility of listing. The United States has a registration-based system, and the market will test whether your enterprise can stand firm in the capital market. If you encounter a specific problem that you really can't cross, then I would like to remind you: have you found the right people? Are your experts and consultants suitable and competent? This point, please entrepreneurs reflect on it yourself.
Expert Services
Host - Jiao Shike:
From your professional perspective, what services can you provide for entrepreneurs?
Guest - Li Songwei:
In terms of overseas listings, our Yingke Law Firm can provide three types of legal services for enterprises:
The first type: Specialized Chinese legal counsel services for overseas listings.
Main tasks include: establishing overseas structures, issuing due diligence investigation reports, participating in the drafting and revision of prospectuses, participating in responding to inquiries from overseas securities regulatory authorities, issuing Chinese legal opinions, etc.
The second type: Specialized legal counsel services for domestic Chinese filings for overseas listings.
Main tasks include: participating in the drafting and revision of filing reports, reviewing and revising other filing documents, participating in responding to inquiries from the China Securities Regulatory Commission, issuing domestic legal opinions, etc.
The third type: Annual legal counsel services for the Early Bird Program for overseas listings.
Main tasks include: participating in sorting out and refining business models, straightening out intra-group related relationships, assisting with business expansion and mergers and acquisitions, assisting with corporate governance and compliance, participating in the early-stage planning of enterprises entering the capital market, etc.
Enterprises can freely choose among our three service products based on their own development status and listing process.
Enterprises that have already started the listing process can choose the Specialized Chinese Legal Counsel Services for Overseas Listings, or the Specialized Legal Counsel Services for Domestic Chinese Filings for Overseas Listings, or both.
Enterprises that are not yet ready to start the listing process at this stage can choose the Annual Legal Counsel Services for the Early Bird Program for Overseas Listings. This service product is not expensive, but it can lay a solid foundation for enterprises when they officially start the listing process in the future. It can not only help enterprises avoid detours, but also help them save overall listing costs.
We hope that aspiring entrepreneurs will grow and strengthen their companies and build them into internationally renowned enterprises. Our Yingke Law Firm is willing to wholeheartedly provide assistance and services for you.
Thank you, entrepreneurs, for your attention, and thank you all for watching this live broadcast!
Originally published on 金盒企业管理集团




